One is not allowed to hit one's servants, even as a means to force them to obey.
One may hit one's own children - including adopted children - if done in a way that will educate them to be upright people.
Before hitting, one should first try explaining the issue; if that fails and one must resort to hitting, one must be careful not to be cruel; one may not beat up a kid to vent one's anger.
It is forbidden to forewarn a child that they will be hit later, as this can traumatize a child. If hitting is called for, one either hits or one keeps quiet about it.
It is forbidden to hit children who will hit back - even if they are not yet Bar Mitzva - since one causes them to sin.
Source: Kitzur Shulchan Aruch 184:2, 143:18: 165:1
- Danny
Wednesday, 22 Tevet 5771
Wednesday, December 29, 2010
Halocho #713 - Hitting as an educational tool
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment